| Edwin F. Whiting | 1865-67 | * |
| Benjamin F. Batchelder | 1868-69 | *1 |
| H. Eugene Leland | 1870-71 | * |
| Orrin Thomson | 1872-73 | * |
| George L. Sanborn | 1874,1877 | *1 |
| Charles C. Abbot | 1875-76 | * |
| Theodore E. Andrews | 1878 | * |
| George M. French | 1879-80 | * | Ralesmon L. Partridge | 1881 | * |
| Nathan W. Philbrook | 1882-83 | *1 |
| John D. Perkins | 1884-85 | * |
| Frank Cass | 1886-87 | * |
| Harrington C. Kingman | 1888-90 | * |
| George A. Barlet | 1891 | * |
| Joseph H. Morrill | 1892-93 | * |
| John H. Andrews | 1894 | * |
| Jarvis B. Woolford | 1895 | *3 |
| Josiah B. Parkim | 1896-98 | * |
| Fred C. Tenney | 1899-1900 | * |
| Henry M. Cutler | 1901-02 | *3 |
| Watson P. Gage | 1903 | * |
| Frank O. Young | 1904-05 | * |
| John E. Talbot | 1906-07 | * |
| George T. Robbins | 1908-09 | * |
| W. Eugene H. Phillips | 1910 | *1 |
| Frank E. Travis | 1911-12 | * |
| Alden R. Newhall | 1913-14 | * |
| Clayton T. Joslyn | 1915 | *1 |
| Arthur L. Pond | 1916-17 | * |
| Edgar W. Reemie | 1918-19 | * |
| James Inches | 1920-21 | *4 |
| Fred B. Wright | 1922 | * |
| Howard S. Wells | 1923 | * |
| Walter F. Wentworth | 1924-25 | * |
| William R. Phipps | 1926-27 | * |
| George V. Moody | 1928-29 | * |
| Joseph Henry Milligan | 1930 | *2 |
| Thomas A. Gooch | 1931 | * |
| Benjamin F. Barnes | 1932 | * |
| Robert Briggs Peckham | 1933 | * |
| Ernest Albert Smith | 1934 | * |
| A. Maurice Merritt | 1935 | * |
| Frank L. Pfeiffer | 1936 | *4 |
| Lyle W. Orton | 1937 | * |
| Norman S. McCallister | 1938 | * |
| Edward A. Lund | 1939 | * |
| Aleden Leland | 1940 | * |
| H. Gordon Weston | 1941 | *4 |
| Edward S. Holbrook | 1942 | *3 |
| Harold F. Ball | 1943 | * |
| Charles H. Cole | 1944 | |
| Allan R. Bliss | 1945 | *3 |
| Ronald G. Robbins | 1946 | * |
| J. Roger Harrington | 1947 | *4 |
| R. Irving Blanchard, Jr. | 1948 | 1 |
| Henry A. Chesmore | 1949 | * |
|
| W. Richard Phipps | 1950 | |
| Fredrick F. Cole | 1951 | * |
| Melvin A. Dill | 1952 | * |
| David E. Richards | 1953 | * |
| H. Gordon Weston, Jr. | 1954 | |
| Norman R. Gillin | 1955 | 1,4 |
| Charles D. Fisher, Jr. | 1956 | * |
| Lester C. Potter | 1957 | 1 |
| William K. Jones | 1958 | * |
| Norman H. Verkruysse | 1959 | |
| Gordon R. Raymond | 1960 | 1 |
| Oliver A. Raney. | 1961 | * |
| Richard I. Mitchell, Sr. | 1962 | 1* |
| Fredrick D. A. King, Jr. | 1963 | 1* |
| Wilbur A. Wraase | 1964 | * |
| Charles M. Abraham | 1965 | 1 |
| Raymond S. Withe | 1966 | *4 |
| Donald J. Mackinnon | 1967 | *5 |
| Martin A. Nitzsche | 1968 |   |
| Douglas A. Barrows | 1969 | *1 |
| Gilbert L. Schofield | 1970 | |
| Don C. H. Beebe, Jr. | 1971 | |
| Douglas A. Brown. | 1972 | |
| Albert T. Beedle | 1973 | |
| D. Craig Travers | 1974 | |
| Samuel P. Blake, Sr. | 1975 | 1,3 |
| Wallace R. Walker | 1976 | *3 |
| Jack E. Anderson | 1977 | 4 |
| David H. Higinbotham | 1978 | |
| Ralph D. Proctor, Jr. | 1979 | * |
| Joe M. Nelson | 1980 | |
| C. Alan Rowe | 1981 | |
| Carl E. Chellquist | 1982 | |
| Peter B. Low | 1983 | |
| Jospeh T. Iwaniec | 1984 | *1 |
| Brenton V. Schofield | 1985 | * |
| Theodore A. Hatch | 1986-87 | |
| Walter J. Warring | 1988-89 | |
| John C. Mulhall | 1990-91 | 3,8 |
| Robert A. Smith | 1992 | |
| Alan G. Schofield | 1993 | |
| Kenneth S. Boyd | 1994 | 6 |
| Robert J. Pratt, Jr. | 1995-96 | |
| John M. Nelson | 1997-98 | |
| Walter H. Hunt | 1999 | 7 |
| James E. Tomasetti | 2000 | |
| Richard A. Casavant | 2001 | |
| Douglas D. Vickery | 2002 | |
| Louis R. Raneri | 2003 | |
| Scott D. Chalfin | 2004-05 | |
| Walter H. Hunt | 2006 | 7 |
|